Visit Tasha's Web site



Visit Laura's Web site



Visit Regina's Web site



Visit Diana's Web site



Visit Sara's Web site

  • Miss Snark
  • Off The Page
  • Elizabeth Peters
  • A Newbie's Guide to Publishing
  • Amelia Peabody
  • Naked Authors
  • Edwardian State of Mind
  • Reviewed by Liz
  • The Girl Detective Blog
  • Poisoned Pen Letters
  • Meritorious Mysteries
  • Renee Rosen
  • The Outfit
  • The Lipstick Chronicles
  • Refrigerator Door
  • Grace Notes
  • Overboard
  • Murderati
  • The Little Blog of Murder
  • Heather Webber
  • The Sphere
  • Alexandra Sokoloff
  • Laurie R. King -- Mutterings
  • Judy Merrill Larson
  • First Offenders
  • Book Square
  • Anatomy of a Book Deal
  • Surrounded on Three Sides
  • Killer Year
  • Book Daddy
  • Contemporary Nomad
  • Confessions of an Idiosyncratic Mind
  • J.T. Ellison
  • Rosett Writes Blog
  • Femmes Fatales
  • Bookseller Chick
  • Tim Maleeny
  • Will Bereswill's blog
  • Galleycat
  • Cozy Chicks Blog
  • Julia Buckley
  • Kill Zone Authors
  • uberlonelyguy16
  • A Dark Planet
  • Murder She Writes
  • Tess Gerritsen
  • Debutante Ball
  • Southern Comfort
  • What Fresh Hell is This?
  • Sarah Stewart Taylor
  • I want to read more posts about:











      View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...
    Polls Archive

    Archives by Month
    Archives by Author
    Design by
    DreamForge Media

    Meta:
    RSS 2.0
    Comments RSS 2.0
    Valid XHTML
    WP

    Two Minds ARE Better Than One

    Laura Bradford Icon

    I’m a huge fan of brainstorming sessions. Always have been.

    I first discovered their appeal as a news reporter. The editor would summon the writers to a small, windowless conference room every Tuesday morning. We’d talk about what worked in the last paper and what didn’t. We batted around ideas for features and ongoing news series.

    What I liked about those get-togethers was seeing what a group of creative minds can do. It was a rare occurrence for one writer to completely take the idea of another, yet those shared thoughts were always springboards to something bigger and better. They made us think beyond where we were.

    I see that in my fiction writing as well. In fact, brainstorming with a fellow writer now is a real treat for me. Again, I rarely use something exactly the way it was offered, but the ideas batted around make me think deeper.

    Most of my brainstorming sessions have happened with my best friend. We’ve talked through ideas during instant message chats, long car rides, and—when possible—while sitting on the same couch in the same city.

    When you are focused on coming up with the premise of a book it can often be hard to see all the angles. Shooting it around with a fellow writer enables them to see plot holes you might have missed.

    About two months ago, I was intrigued by one minor aspect of a news story I’d seen on my splash screen. It stuck with me over the next few days and, before long, I knew I wanted to work it into a story. Slowly but surely I concocted a basic premise that excited me more and more as I mulled it over. Yet, I couldn’t start writing because I didn’t have my who and my why—two aspects I have to have in place before I can put my story to paper.

    During that stalled phase, I had the opportunity to meet my friend, Joe. We hadn’t talked face to face in a while so we spent some time catching up on life stuff. When we were done I gave him the basic premise of my story idea. Or, what I had of it at that point.

    Without going into too much detail, the protagonist of this story returns to the scene of a past tragedy. While there she uncovers a threat to her own life.

    Joe, being the amazing brainstorming partner that he is, asked for some of my who/why ideas. I threw a few of them out as they formulated in my brain. Each time he’d say, “yeah, but he’d just kill her.”

    I’d throw out another option.

    “Yeah, but he’d just kill her.”

    And another.

    “Yeah, but he’d just kill her.”

    And finally one last one.

    Same response.

    On one hand the whole devil’s advocate thing he was playing with me was walking the line of infuriating, on the other hand I could feel that creative part of my brain really churning through what he was saying.

    When we parted ways, I still had no ideas. Just a bunch of his questions firing away in my mind, attacking everything I came up with. But I kept at it. Kept thinking. Kept questioning.

    I was about ten miles from home when it hit. WHAM!

    I had the why as it pertained to the threat. And it was dynamite!

    It was enough to start writing. Wrote the first chapter and showed it to my best friend when she came in for a visit a week ago. She loved it. But as we talked about what I had in mind, I realized I needed another layer to my why. I already had some of it, thanks to a pick-your-brain session with someone in the particular field my motive explores, but still didn’t have it completely nailed down.

    Again went the questions. The ideas. The shoot-downs. The grunts. The frustrated sighs.

    And, once again, it paid off. Big time.

    There are lots of things I’ve learned as a writer. Both with fiction and non-fiction. Little tips and ideas that have strengthened my desire and my skill with each new project. But if I had to pinpoint one thing that I value the most in terms of the creative aspect of writing, it’s the opportunity to sit down with a like-minded person and let the mind wander.

    It always ends up somewhere better than it originated.

    Always.

    So, how about you guys? Do you find talking stuff out—whether a story idea or something in your personal life—pays off for you? Or are you more apt to concoct and execute totally on your own?

    Hugs,
    ~Laura

    27 Responses to “Two Minds ARE Better Than One”

    1. My husband and I have worked together for most of our 21 years of marriage - at something like seven different companies. While this can often be stressful, we do have that creative jam session relationship that you describe and apply it to projects. I love staying up late into the night and hammering out an idea with him. Whatever it is we are working on is always better when we put it through this process.

      by Liz on August 7th, 2007 at 6:36 am

    2. I’m right there with you, Laura in that as infuriating as brainstorming can be (the whole, “yeah but he’d just kill her” effect), it’s what jumpstarts all those ideas. Just yesterday I spent over one hour on the phone with one of my agent’s readers–we hashed out all sorts of things, she threw out tons of ideas while I scribbled furiously. Then, over dinner, I chatted about all of it with my husband. Today, my mind is still churning out possible plot points and character flaws and strengths. I don’t know if I’ll be able to write fast enough but it feels great.

      p.s Welcome back!

      by judy larsen on August 7th, 2007 at 7:06 am

    3. Laura, I use various versions of brainstorming all the time. Being in the corporate arena for as long as I’ve been, I remember when “Brainstorming” first hit the corporate scene. In the early 1980’s, someone wrote a book and corporate America gobbled it up. There were all kinds of rules:

      Your group had to have a wide crossection, such as a marketing person, a secretary, an engineer, a saleman, a technician, etc.

      You spent 5 minutes reviewing the problem, 10 minutes brainstorming, and then an evaluation period.

      No one was allowed to critique an idea until the brainstorming session was done.

      Over the years, I’ve seen these things come and go, but I use variations of those rules all the time. For instance, I believe in getting feedback from a wide variety of people. Ironically, some of the worst feedback I’ve received have been from other writers. The best feedback was from a scriptwriter who gave me an amazing piece of advise without knowing it.

      My most enjoyable brainstorming is done on long walks with my wife. I use that time to build my characters. We go over backgrounds, personalities, habits, etc.

      by Will Bereswill on August 7th, 2007 at 7:12 am

    4. Since Theo is invariably the smartest guy in the room, brainstorming won’t work. Theo can’t have one of you lesser lights befouling one of his many brilliant ideas.

      Theo is a one man think-tank.

      by Theo Epstein on August 7th, 2007 at 8:09 am

    5. I love talking out plot, but I feel sorry for whoever’s subjected to my erratic babbling during the process.

      by Tasha Alexander on August 7th, 2007 at 8:42 am

    6. I love brainstorming! I always come away with tons of good ideas and enthusiasm(sp?).

      by Becky on August 7th, 2007 at 8:44 am

    7. I feel the same way, Tasha. Sometimes I wonder why my friends still talk to me! :wink:

      by Becky on August 7th, 2007 at 9:08 am

    8. I work alone. I find if I talk too much about the work it lessens my enthusiasm for writing it.

      Robert Frost had the same feeling. He said that talking about the work was like opening a fire hydrant outside of the house. It lowered the water pressure inside the house.

      I’m with him.

      by David Terrenoire on August 7th, 2007 at 9:13 am

    9. Stealing a term from “Meet the Parents”, its a “Circle of Trust” with me. I will brainstorm with people I trust. However, with that said, I have gone out on a limb to discuss things with new people that have a certain expertise I lack and have gotten some great results.

      by Will Bereswill on August 7th, 2007 at 9:41 am

    10. Liz, I think that would be cool to have a built in brainstorming partner on the same sheet. Very neat!

      Judy, we must talk! Were these notes on something new??? How close are you now to finishing? And thanks…JUST walked back in the door after a 16 1/2 hour drive.

      by Laura on August 7th, 2007 at 12:50 pm

    11. Will, interesting comment on the feedback from other writers. I think you have to brainstorm with the right people. If you have a wet blanket type, who enjoys monkeying with everything, it’s no good.

      Theo, YES you are most certainly a one man think tank.

      by Laura on August 7th, 2007 at 12:52 pm

    12. Tasha, no one thinks you babble… :wink: Almost called you during my long drive today. For some girl chat. You were spared though.

      Becky, sounds like you’d be a fun one to brainstorm with! Those who truly love the process are the most fun to work with.

      by Laura on August 7th, 2007 at 12:53 pm

    13. David, I’m the opposite. I get MORE energy when I throw stuff out. I never come up with my final idea in that setting, but it gets the wheels turning and the enthusiasm flowing.

      by Laura on August 7th, 2007 at 12:54 pm

    14. Laura,

      I love that verb, to monkey. I heard it a lot when I was a kid but not so much today. I wonder why that is.

      It’s even better than futz.

      by David Terrenoire on August 7th, 2007 at 1:06 pm

    15. David, I tend to revert to old slang. To monkey…knock it off…cut it out. All favorites. And I remember futz. “Stop futzing around.”

      Ahhh. The good old days.

      by Laura on August 7th, 2007 at 1:11 pm

    16. You did all the brainstorming, my friend. I just sat back and enjoyed the coffee and company. The latter far more than the former, of course. Hope you had a wonderful trip…

      by Joe on August 7th, 2007 at 1:44 pm

    17. Joe, your devil’s advocate hat that day was truly invaluable. At the moment, of course, I wanted to secure a muzzle to your mouth to keep you from saying, “yeah, but he’d just kill her” yet again. But when I got in the car and THE motive came to me, I realized how much I had needed that. thanks! Trip was great! Could have stayed another few days if school supply shopping and teacher visits hadn’t been looming.

      by Laura on August 7th, 2007 at 2:31 pm

    18. Well, Laura, I know sometimes it just helps to talk through something. Most times, the other person doesn’t have to say a word. It’s an old auditor trick. Ask am open ended question and then listen. When the person stops talking, keep your mouth shut and listen some more. People hate silence. For most it’s uncomfortable. Most times they’ll give away way more information than they want to.

      If you ever need a good listener, you know where to find me.

      BTW I got my advance from H&H.

      by Will Bereswill on August 7th, 2007 at 2:40 pm

    19. I’d rather hear “devil’s advocate” than “you’re ruining my story!” LOL. Brainstorming is usually a great creative outlet, but usually I’m too much of a control freak for it to actually help me.

      by Heather on August 7th, 2007 at 3:34 pm

    20. Will, I’m picturing a hanging lamp, swaying in a windowless room.

      heather, I can say these things to you though. :mrgreen: I treasure all our B.S. sessions.

      by Laura on August 7th, 2007 at 3:38 pm

    21. LOL on the “B.S.” sessions. What are you trying to say??? :)

      by Heather on August 7th, 2007 at 3:44 pm

    22. We always intersperse our BrainStorming with a little of that too… We’re girls. We like to yak.

      by Laura on August 7th, 2007 at 3:45 pm

    23. Regardling girls liking to yak… At one point in a Spenser novel, Susan Silverman says “I’m a female Jewish shrink. You expect long silences?”

      (Or something very close to that. I don’t have the book at hand.)

      Most of my behind-the-scenes work is ways I’ve found of brainstorming with myself. I figure if you’ve got a nature that takes one look at something and says “I could do it better than that schmuck,” you find a way to harness it.

      by Keith on August 8th, 2007 at 10:55 am

    24. :mrgreen: on the Spenser novel, Keith.

      I would love to hear how you go about brainstorming with yourself. Do you talk it through out loud?

      by Laura on August 8th, 2007 at 11:53 am

    25. This is my first visit to your blog and I hit one of my favorite topics. I find that even if the person I’m brainstorming with gives me a bad idea, figuring out why it’s bad — or bad for my book- helps me figure out what’s right. I brainstorm with my writers group, my husband, brothers, and often my research sources. It’s new energy into the book, a real gift from a friend.

      by Jan Brogan on August 8th, 2007 at 1:30 pm

    26. Laura,

      I’ve got a method of brainstorming with myself. Read the last chapter/paragraphs you wrote. Immediately grab your iPod with some hard driving dance/aerobic non-vocal music, turn up the volume and walk hard, or jog. Concentrate on the road or path in front of you and let your mind slip into the last thing you read.

      Most times, in a few minutes, I’m playing the story out in my bored mind. Dialog is forming, the plot advances, etc.

      Depending on the circumstances, I find myself pushing the plot or dialog, and normally with great results. I carry a digital voice recorder to keep track of the really good stuff. Although my recordings sound out-of-breath and loud.

      by Will Bereswill on August 8th, 2007 at 3:25 pm

    27. Welcome, Jan, glad you found us! You know, you’re exactly right. Even the bad idea still turns something in my mind. Gives a springboard too, I guess.

      Will, I’ve never tried a voice recorder though it sounds neat. I carry my trusty notebook everywhere I go. Although I don’t pull it out as often as I should, it does help.

      by Laura on August 8th, 2007 at 4:53 pm

    Leave a Reply

    :) :D :( :o 8O :? 8) :lol: :x :P :oops: :cry: :evil: :twisted: :roll: :wink: :!: :?: :idea: :arrow: :| :mrgreen: